Background: Fansly vs OF
OnlyFans was created in 2016 and has been the larger platform for adult content. It became especially popular during the pandemic.
Fansly, on the other hand, launched in 2020. However, it only got traction in 2021 after OnlyFans announced plans to ban adult content. This prompted many adult creators to migrate to Fansly.
Although OnlyFans quickly reversed this decision, Fansly had already started to establish itself as a strong competitor. Today, both platforms are leading choices for adult content creators.
In the following sections, you'll discover crucial factors to help you decide which platform fits your needs best.
Difference between Fansly and OnlyFans
Both platforms have a lot of similarities, but here's how they differ:
Audience and reach
OnlyFans
OnlyFans has a massive user base, with over 190 million registered users and 3 million content creators. If you join, you'll have access to a huge audience.
That said, OnlyFans is very competitive. It can be tough when you're new to the platform.
The good news is that OnlyFans is popular, and people already trust and use the platform. This can make it easier for you to convert visitors into paying subscribers.
Fansly
Fansly is newer and smaller than OnlyFans, but it's been gaining popularity. The site has 130 million active users and over 2 million content creators.
As such, there's less competition on Fansly. So, you might find it easier to get noticed, especially if you have a great niche.
However, many people still don't know about Fansly, and you may have to convince them to open an account. Because of this, it can be tougher to get subscribers.
Monetization options
OnlyFans and Fansly have the same monetization options. You can set a monthly subscription fee, offer paid direct messages, and receive tips from fans who want to support you.
Both platforms let you charge for live streaming. They also have a referral program that allows you to receive a percentage of the referred creator's earnings.
But there's a bit of difference:
OnlyFans
You can set a monthly subscription price for your content. But the price ranges from $4.99 to
$49.99 per month. Your subscription rate can't be beyond 49.99 per month.
Plus, OnlyFans allows you to set only 1 subscription tier, unlike Fansly, which gives you a bit more flexibility.
Also, keep in mind that, unlike Fansly, OnlyFans allows you to sell merch. So that can be another income source for you.
Fansly
Subscription prices on Fansly can start at $4.99 and go all the way to $499.99. Also, on OnlyFans, regular users can tip up to $200 at a time. Over on Fansly, the maximum single tip amount is a whopping $500.
Additionally, Fansly allows you to offer different subscription tiers. This means you can charge a lower fee for access to some of your private content and a higher fee for additional content, like longer videos.
Fansly vs OF: Fansly has a tier subscription feature for better content managment.
It's a useful feature, but it requires more effort. Many creators prefer having a single tier because it's simpler to manage.
Income potential
Whether you join Fansly or OnlyFans, your earnings will depend largely on the number of subscribers you attract. Other factors include how much you charge and the additional income from customs and tips.
Generally, OnlyFans has an edge here because it's a well-known name, and you're likely to get more buyers here.
OnlyFans
Top OnlyFans creators can make big money, sometimes six or seven figures a year. The top earners bring in $4,000 or more each month, but only about 10% of creators hit larger figures.
On average, creators earn between $180 and $500 a month from subscriptions. As a newcomer, you'll need to put in a lot of marketing effort to stand out and start earning.
Fansly
On average, Fansly creators earn between $180 and $250 per month. Some big creators have claimed to be making between $5,000 and $7,000 a month.
While that can be true, only a few creators truly make this much on the site. Also, keep in mind that many people have yet to make any money from the site.
Fansly has slightly more flexible monetization options, such as lower minimum tips. Tips start at $1, unlike OnlyFans, which starts at $5. This can encourage more frequent transactions and engagement from subscribers.
Payouts and fees
Both Fansly and OnlyFans take a 20% commission on all earnings. Creators keep 80% of their earnings on both platforms.
The difference here lies in payout frequency:
OnlyFans
OnlyFans payout is simple. They hold your earnings for a 7-day period before you can access them.
If you're in a smaller country, the holding period is longer—21 days for the first four months—but it switches to the usual 7 days afterward.
Once you request a payout, you'll typically see the money in your account within 3 to 5 business days. And you'll need at least $20 in your account to request a withdrawal.
OnlyFans supports payouts through bank transfer, e-wallet, Venmo, and Paxum. However, it doesn't offer PayPal because of the platform's adult content.
Fansly
Fansly also has a 7-day holding period for earnings. However, this platform is known for its fast payout processing. They typically complete withdrawals within 1-2 business days.
Fansly accepts more payment options than OnlyFans, including Skrill, Paxum, cryptocurrency, and bank transfers. Unfortunately, they don't support PayPal, either.
The minimum payout thresholds vary depending on the payment method you use:
$20 for Paxum and Cosmopayment
$50 for SEPA transfers within the EU and UK
$100 for international bank wire transfers (SWIFT)
$100 for cryptocurrency
Features
Fansly vs OnlyFans, which has better features? None of them is impressive yet. However, Fansly is putting more effort into making their platform user-friendly.
OnlyFans
OnlyFans allows you to schedule your posts to go live at the best time for posting. This way, you can keep your content consistently flowing without having to be online all the time.
You can also organize your fans and messages into categories or lists. This helps you manage your interactions more effectively. Fansly doesn't have this.
Plus, OnlyFans offers an advanced statistics page to help you understand and optimize your profile better. You can also engage with your audience through community polls, quizzes, and stories that last 24 hours.
Fansly
Fansly has a search feature that allows users to look up creators or keywords right on the platform. OnlyFans doesn't offer this. This small difference can make a big impact, helping fans and creators connect more easily.
There's also a "For You" page which allows creators to get discovered. It features trending and recommended content, which can include your posts. This means your content has a higher chance of being seen by users who might not follow you yet.
Fansly lets users follow creators and preview their content before deciding to subscribe, which can help creators attract new subscribers.
Just like OnlyFans, it has a mass messaging feature that lets you send pay-per-view content to all your followers at once.
Fansly also provides detailed analytics to help you track audience engagement and earnings, giving you better insights into your performance. They're always rolling out new features and updating their community on X.
User experience and interface
OnlyFans
One major criticism of OnlyFans is its poor browsing experience. Finding and discovering new creators is a hassle. Some users even complain about buying the same content twice because there's no way to tell whether you've bought it before. Whereas, with Fansly, you can tell.
Fansly
Based on creator reviews on Reddit, Fansly has a slightly superior user interface compared to OnlyFans. Creators appreciate its ease of use, especially the ability to manage both free and paid content within a single account.
Fansly, unlike OnlyFans, allows fans to "discover" creators through the "For you" page. Despite this, Fansly users still rely heavily on outside promotion. To get more subscribers, you need to direct traffic from other social media platforms like Twitter, Instagram, TikTok, and Reddit.
Use Social Rise to schedule Reddit posts for the week in minutes, and drive subscribers to your OnlyFans or Fansly.
Content restrictions and policies
OnlyFans
OnlyFans has a long list of banned words and content that violate their terms of service. This can be frustrating if you like to push boundaries with more daring content.
Is Fansly better than OnlyFans? Yes, Fansly is more lenient with kinky content.
The platform's earlier attempt to ban sexual content in 2021 still keeps creators on edge, as there's always a concern it might happen again.
Despite all the restrictions, OnlyFans still supports a wide range of kinky content. And such creators thrive on the platform.
Fansly
Fansly, on the other hand, has been more relaxed with its content rules. It allows videos on topics like cannabis and lactation, which attracts a unique group of creators and followers who are interested in those niches.
Support and community
Both OnlyFans and Fansly have active subreddits. The subreddits are perfect for users to find new profiles and for creators to promote themselves.
The OnlyFans subreddit is much bigger, with around five times more subscribers than Fansly's. But don't let that fool you—Fansly's community is still huge and full of potential fans just waiting to become your next paying subscribers. There's also a community of fellow creators ready to offer advice.
OnlyFans
When it comes to customer support, the story isn't so great. OnlyFans proudly boasts about their support network on their website, claiming they're always ready to help their community. But they often fall short of this promise.
Onlyfans vs Fansly - OnlyFans support reviews are mostly negative.
OnlyFans' popularity and big brand name might be the cause. They struggle to keep up with the high demand. In reality, you might end up waiting up to a week for a response to your requests. And even when they do reply, it can be unhelpful.
Fansly
People generally praise Fansly's customer service for being responsive and helpful, especially through social media channels. They manage to maintain good support despite rapid growth, and they often provide quick, useful responses.
However, navigating their website for help can be challenging if you haven't signed up. They have very limited and hard-to-find FAQs.
Security and privacy
Both sites use automatic watermarks on your content. This helps protect your content against theft and IP infringement.
If someone tries to steal your content, they'll have to remove the watermark first, and that's not easy. Plus, you can easily prove it's yours by showing the watermarked version and getting the content taken down.
OnlyFans and Fansly also offer a geoblocking tool. This tool lets you block access to your content from specific regions. Geoblocking is perfect if you want to keep your posts private from family and friends who live in those areas.
Which one is better: Fansly or OnlyFans?
In a Reddit survey of 375 content people, creators were asked, is Fansly or OnlyFans better? 33.8% preferred Fansly, while 22.9% went with OnlyFans.
Creators often find Fansly easier to use. The site is growing fast, so getting in early could be beneficial as it becomes more popular. They're also constantly updating their tech, which shows a lot of promise.
On the other hand, OnlyFans has a huge, hard-to-beat user base. Since it's been around since 2016, OnlyFans is more accessible for beginners. It's reliable, and building a following there can be quicker. The potential for making money is also higher on OnlyFans, mostly because the site has more traffic.
Both platforms have pros and cons, which is why many creators end up using both. In fact, 43.2% of the survey participants said they use both. Creators tend to make OnlyFans their main site while having Fansly as a backup.
Fansly or OnlyFans? Some creators use both.
In the end, what's important is that you find which one best fits your needs and preferences.
FAQ about Fansly vs OnlyFans
Is Fansly the same as OnlyFans?
No, Fansly is not the same as OnlyFans. They are two different platforms. But if you're wondering, is Fansly like Onlyfans? Yes it is. They're both known as sites where people buy and sell adult content. And they operate in almost the same way. OnlyFans is the more popular one. Fansly, though also popular, is newer and doesn't have as many users.
Can I have a Fansly account as a backup?
Yes, creating a Fansly account as a backup to your OnlyFans can be a smart move. Simply repost your OnlyFans content on Fansly. This way, you avoid the need to create different content for each platform, while broadening your chances of earning more. But if you're leaning towards creating different content for the separate platforms, it might be better to concentrate your efforts on one platform. You can achieve more focused and effective results without feeling overwhelmed this way.
Should I be worried that OnlyFans will die?
No, you shouldn't be. OnlyFans have been around for some time and they're not likely to die anytime soon. But to prevent excessive loss in case they die, your focus should be on marketing and building an audience on other social media. This way, whether onlyfans die or not, you always have a strong audience that you can direct to a new adult content platform.
Is Fansly better than OnlyFans for making money as a creator?
Some creators say they've earned more from Fansly than from OnlyFans. Others say they've had more success with OnlyFans. OnlyFans is the safer choice. It has more traffic, and buyers trust it more. However, if you put in the work, you can make money on any of the platforms.
Conclusion: OnlyFans vs Fansly
Audience and reach: OnlyFans has a larger audience, whereas Fansly doesn't receive as much traffic. Therefore, OnlyFans is the better fit if you want to gain subscribers fast.
Monetization: Both platforms offer the same monetization options, but Fansly gives more flexibility with tiered subscription options.
Income: OnlyFans creators typically make more money because it's easier to direct subscribers to OnlyFans. But Fansly is new, and users can consider setting up an account a hassle.
Payouts and fees: They both hold payments for seven days and collect a 20% fee. OnlyFans takes 3-5 days to process payment, while Fansly takes 1-2 days.
Features: Both sites offer limited features, but Fansly is doing a better job of making their site more user-friendly.
Interface: OnlyFans is basic and outdated, while Fansly is a bit cleaner and easier to use.
Support: OnlyFans customer support is poor, while Fansly's support is fast and helpful.
Fansly vs OF, which is better? It depends on what you need and value as a creator.
